Criminal Law Consulting
​For Writers & Filmmakers
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Free eBook

Get Your Free Writer's Guide: Top Seven Mistakes Made By Writers of Crime, Mystery and Legal Drama

10/14/2011

4 Comments

 
I have almost completed my first free Writer's Guide.  It is called Top Seven Mistakes Made By Writers of Crime, Mystery and Legal Drama.  

There are common mistakes that I see again and again in crime and criminal law scenes in books, on television and in movies.  Such mistakes, which are often trivial to the story, can take away from the authenticity and credibility of the entire work. 

I am creating this free Writer's Guide to help writers of crime, mystery and legal drama avoid these common mistakes and write with more authenticity. 

You can be among the first to receive this valuable Writer's Guide.  I will only make this free Writer's Guide available for a limited time, so sign up today!  Make sure you're not making these common mistakes!
4 Comments

How To Choose an Expert Consultant - 7 Tips

10/12/2011

0 Comments

 
Yesterday, I discussed five tips for non-lawyers writing about crime and criminal law.  The last tip was to consult an expert to review your draft or answer your questions.  Once you decide you could use some advice from an expert consultant, how do you choose one? 

Here are a few things to consider:

1.  Expertise:  Make sure the person you're consulting is an actual expert.  Do they have real world experience as well as book smarts about the topics you're interested in?

2.  Simplicity:  Can the expert discuss complex legal issues in a way that is easy for a non-lawyer to understand?

3.  Passion:  You want to work with someone who loves what they do and loves what you're doing.

4.  Educating:  A good expert educates at every opportunity (whether they're being paid or not).  You 'll learn the most from someone who naturally and constantly shares their knowledge.

5.  Time:  Make sure the expert you're consulting with has time for you and your project.  If your emails or phone calls aren't being answered in a reasonable time (like 24 hours), start looking elsewhere. 

6.  Flexible pricing:  Not every project or consultation is the same.  An expert should be flexible enough in their pricing to work with your budget and needs.  Sometimes a project may require a flat fee, an hourly rate, or a per page rate.  Look for someone who is open to your particular needs.

7.  Free initial consultation:  Any expert consultant worth their salt will be willing to spend time to get to know you and your project before charging.  A free initial consultation allows you to feel out the consultant and decide whether they will be right for you and your project.

Contact me for a free initial consultation.
0 Comments

Writing Authentic Crime or Legal Fiction - 5 Tips

10/11/2011

4 Comments

 
Taking on a subject like crime or criminal law can be intimidating.  In the world of criminal law, there are innumerable rules, practices and procedures.  Criminal lawyers speak their own language.  To write a good crime or legal story, a writer needs to have credibility. 

Credibility comes from understanding and working with the rules of criminal law and from speaking the criminal law language.  But you don’t have to be a cop or lawyer to write about crime or criminal law with authenticity.  Here are five tips to get started:

1.  Brainstorm:  Physically write out brainstorming ideas without regard to order, quality or completeness.  Just start writing, and let the ideas flow.  Creating a great plot and characters is the first step in any genre.

2.  Get Inspired:  Read great crime books, and watch great legal drama movies.  Read about crime in the news.  Follow interesting trials.  Watch true crime stories on television and read true crime books.  You never know when something you read or see will spark your next story.

3.  Outline:  Whether organized by chapter, act, scene, character or plot point, outlining is a critical organizational tool.  The more complex the story, the more important an outline.  Outlining can be especially important in a crime novel or legal drama because your story needs to fit within the rules of the criminal law world. 

4.  Educate Yourself:  Read up about criminal law on the internet and in books.  Look for information specifically targeted to the non-lawyer, like that in the Rescources section here.  Watch real trials.  Watch true crime shows and read news stories and true crime books (but be aware that they often leave out details you might want to know).  Do not rely on talking head lawyer commentators or other criminal law fiction. 

5.  Consult an Expert:  When in doubt, ask a question.  As you brainstorm, outline and draft, keep notes of questions that come up.  Then find an expert you can use as a trusted resource. 

Check out tomorrow's post about how to choose an expert consultant.  Contact me for a free initial consultation.

Following these tips will give you confidence to create within the world of criminal law and to write crime and legal stories with authenticity.
4 Comments

A Circumstantial Case

10/6/2011

3 Comments

 
People often say things like, "it's just a circumstantial case" or "the evidence was all circumstantial."  They say these things as  if "circumstantial" is code for "weak."   In truth, circumstantial evidence can be just reliable and sometimes even more so than direct evidence.

So what exactly is circumstantial evidence?  It's basically evidence that requires an inference to prove something. 

The most common example is rain.  Say you want proof that it was raining this morning.  Direct evidence would be if someone came in and said, "I saw it raining this morning."  Circumstantial evidence would be if the person said they heard distant pitter-patter and later walked outside and saw the ground was wet, and the air smelled fresh and felt moist.

Would you be any less inclined to believe it had rained under the second scenario?  Probably not.  Of course, the reliability of any evidence, whether direct or circumstantial, is only as good as its source.

For more in-depth information, check out my article on direct versus circumstantial evidence.
3 Comments

Competency versus Insanity

9/29/2011

14 Comments

 
Yesterday, a judge considered the competency of the man charged in the Arizona January shooting rampage that killed six and injured Congresswoman Gabriel Giffords.  Although Jared Loughner has been charged in the case, he cannot go to trial until he has been declared competent to do so.  There was some indication that, once competent to stand trial, he may claim he is not guilty by reason of insanity.

This begs the question:  what is the difference between competency to stand trial and the insanity defense?  There are three basic differences:

The first difference is the timeframe considered.  Determining someone’s competency to stand trial is concerned with their mental state at the time of legal proceedings and trial.  Whether a person can be found not guilty by reason of insanity is determined by looking at the person’s mental state at the time the crime was committed.  So, competency is concerned with today, whereas insanity is concerned with a distinct point in the past.

The second difference is the standard.  Competency is determined by whether the defendant can understand the nature and consequences of the criminal proceedings against him and whether he can assist in his defense. 

The insanity defense varies greatly from state to state.  Federal courts use the M'Naghten test to determine if someone is legally insane.  The M'Naghten test generally asks whether the defendant, because of a defect of reason, either did not understand the nature and quality of his acts or did not know that his acts were wrong.  (Check out this post for more about the insanity defense and the M'Naghten test.)

The third difference is procedural.  Competency is determined by the judge, and must be considered before a trial can take place.  If found incompetent, the defendant is treated in a mental facility and is periodically evaluated to determine whether he has gained competence. 

Insanity is determined by the jury (assuming the defendant has a jury trial).  It is a complete defense to the crime charged.  The idea is that if a person was insane at the time the crime was committed, he or she is excused from responsibility for the crime, and must be found not guilty.  However, being found not guilty by reason of insanity does not mean he goes free.  Generally, the person found legally insane can be locked up in a mental facility until doctors determine he or she is safe to return to society.


For more on the insanity defense, check out this post.
14 Comments

Teen Hate-Crime Trial Exemplifies Murder versus Voluntary Manslaughter

9/21/2011

5 Comments

 
A common question people ask is what is the difference between murder and manslaughter?  The definitions of these crimes vary somewhat from state to state, but a recent California trial provides a good example for generally understanding what constitutes murder versus voluntary manslaughter.

A 14 year old eighth grader shot and killed an openly gay 15 year old classmate.  Evidence showed Larry King had worn high heels and makeup to school, and that he often teased Brandon McInerney.  McInerney brought a gun to school and shot King twice in the back of the head while they were in English class.  He had told a friend the day before that he planned to bring a gun to school the next day.

McInerney was tried as an adult.  The prosecution theory was that this was a first-degree murder, planned, contemplated and discussed in advance, and carried out with conscious intent to kill.  The defense presented the case of an overwhelmed child who felt sexually harassed by the gay teen's unwanted attention and snapped.  There was no dispute that McInerney pulled the trigger.  The only question was his state of mind.

Murder in California is a killing with malice aforethought.  Malice is found when the defendant intended to kill.  If a murder is committed with premeditation and deliberation, it is first-degree murder.  (There are other ways of elevating a murder from second to first degree, but they aren't relevant here.)

A murder can be reduced to voluntary manslaughter if the person acted in the heat of passion.  A killing in the heat of passion requires 1) that the defendant was provoked, 2) that the provocation caused the defendant to act rashly and under the influence of intense emotion that obscured his judgment and reasoning, and 3) the provocation would have caused the average person to act rashly.  In other words, the defendant was so provoked by what the victim did, and reasonably so, that he acted out of intense emotion rather than deliberate judgment.

The jury was unable to make a decision in this case, and a mistrial was declared.  McInerney will have to be tried again.  The jury simply could not decide whether McInerney acted deliberately or in the heat of passion.

UPDATE 11/21/11:  McInerney pled guilty to second-degree murder and voluntary manslaughter, accepting a sentence of 21 years in prison, and avoiding a second trial.

For more about the differences between murder and manslaughter, check out the Resources section. 
5 Comments

"Is This Realistic?"

9/16/2011

0 Comments

 
This is the most common question I get:  a writer has a story idea, a scene, a plot twist or a character action and wants to know, "Is that realistic?"  

A common goal for writers and filmmakers is to create authentic crime and legal elements in their stories.  Would a prosecutor really do that?  Would a witness be allowed to testify to this?  Is this a correct use of a legal objection?    Is that hearsay (and what exactly is "hearsay")?

There are of course a million variations to this question, and that is partly why I decided to offer criminal law consulting services to writers, producers and filmmakers who want to get it right.  (Of course, poetic license allows you to discard reality and do whatever best suits the dramatic needs of your story.  But even then, a writer should at least know the right way and make a conscious and informed decision to do things differently.)

If you have a question about whether a legal scene you're working on is realistic, contact me for a consultation.
0 Comments
Forward>>
    Get your FREE E-Book revealing The Top 7 Mistakes Made by Writers of Crime, Mystery and Legal Drama:
    Send My Free E-Book!

    Author

    Blythe Leszkay is a successful and experienced criminal attorney, criminal law professor, and consultant to writers and filmmakers.  See About Me.  This blog is intended to answer common criminal law questions, dispel misconceptions, and explain misunderstood criminal law concepts.  It is also a place to discuss any crime or law related topics of interest.  Contact me for a free initial consultation on your film or writing project.

    Categories

    All
    Appeals
    Burden Of Proof
    Celebrity Crime
    Common Questions
    Constitution
    Consulting Services
    Courtroom
    Crime In The News
    Crime Novels
    Crime Tv
    Death Penalty
    Defenses
    Evidence
    Extortion
    Hate Crimes
    International Crime
    Juvenile Crime
    Legal Comedy
    Legal Definitions
    Legal Drama
    Manslaughter
    Movies
    Murder
    Search And Seizure
    Serial Killers
    Sex Crimes
    Supreme Court
    Trial
    True Crime
    Writing Tips

    RSS Feed

      Get Email Updates

    Join!
    Loading
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.